AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for A Brand-New Girl

by Hrtofdrkns

person karla
schedule December 28, 2005 at 12:00 AM
i really really like your story! fuck all the flaming bastards who dont!!!
i have a little reccommendation: first of all, your fic is going really well relationship wise, but i would really like to see a dark lemon with inu/kag.

since the beads are off, you could have him turn youkai and no one could stop him. not even a sit. so what angsty, spanky, painful things can happen
when you have an out of control red-eyed demon on your hands? especially to dearest Kagome.
just a small suggestion. i think your tale is pretty good aready, but i highly demand a lemon!!!
keep writing pleeze!
person Emily
schedule December 27, 2005 at 12:00 AM
First, your stories are about you "professor". Any writer who's worth snot knows that at least on a base level they have to relate to their story. You tell a story that you want to hear, want to tell, something you understand and want to share with the world. So saying that you and your story are two completely different things is wrong. Second, in your misplaced desire to correct what you see as a wrong you have destroyed the characters created by someone who is a FAR better story teller then yourself, and that's just sad. Third, while I understand the negative implications of the Rosary, you take it too far. You make people into things and people they are not, you ignore story elements because they aren't convinient to you. No, Kagome is not perfect. But neither is InuYasha, Sango, Miroku, Shippo, Kouga, Kikyo or anyone in the story or on Earth. Fourth, how are you making Kagome a better person, InuYasha someone to be trusted, when you include a sceen where she beats Shippo beyond reason with a hair brush? That's child abuse. Open handed is punishment, what she did is defined by the law as an "attack" and is child abuse. How horrible do you think these people are? Hell, you even have InuYasha watch with glee while she pummels the child. Fifth, Shippo is a young boy, he does what young boys do. He plays tricks and goes too far. However, even the most broken of children (and I work with some of the most broken) would find no humor in what you saw this character doing. The sad part is that all of this sick twisted material is from you. You thought of it. You wrote it. You need to concider what made you create such horror. You aren't a bad person. But your story is. I wish you luck in life.
person Spud
schedule December 27, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Very nice. I do believe Shippo got what he deserved. ^_^ You like them spanks, don't you? Kidding, kidding. Anyway, awesome chapter.
person chanda
schedule December 26, 2005 at 12:00 AM
A twisted Shippo... Look forward until the next chapter.

Chanda
person Rawben
schedule December 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
oh crap... dont do it shippo! lol...
person Lynn
schedule December 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Hello again!

Good chapter, although alow me to point out two thing. In my opinion, Kagome would never spank Shippo. She's just not like that. You gave her enough reason to take off the rosary. I could even imagine her making Shippo to apologize to InuYasha, but not the spanking. Once again, it is just my opinion. Also, Shippo may be a brat, and he goes on Inu's nerves, but he is not cruel. Not like that, anyway. In the series, the only person who's shape he takes on is Kagome, and it is only to make InuYasha feel better. Of course that just annoyes him all the more, but Shippo meant well. So he is annoying all right, but not cruel. I think so, at least.

I don't mean offence with that, it is just what I think, others may think otherwise. You can call that criticism, I guess.
Hope I didn't make you angry or anything.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Lynn
person You don't need to know
schedule December 24, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I really enjoy reading your work, because your fics are 'deeper' than most fanfics and give me something to think about. Anyway please continue with the story.

By the way: This is Inu/Kag romance, right? (please let it be. Anything else I believe is wrong or 'unnatural')
person InuGrrrl
schedule December 24, 2005 at 12:00 AM
LOLOLOL! WOOT!
That was priceless. I'm glad kagome
finally whacked him one. Sometimes
he's such a damn brat! Nice chappie.
person lemon_ice
schedule December 24, 2005 at 12:00 AM
personnaly i disagree with you about the rosary. it happened in wheezambu's the 'youkai and the exterminator' and i didn't particullarily agree with it then. i think that when inuyasha turns into a demon, and even when he REALLY looses his temper he can get out of control. true she MAY have used it a little to much, or on some wrong occasions, but think that the rosary was very neccesary for quite some time. maybe eventually, no strike that, PROBABLY, almost for sure i thinkt that the rosary wouldnt be necdcesary eventually, but i thik that that would still be a long ways away. but then maybe that s when your story is? well whatever, i still went with it, and it was ok. i liked the opening dream sequence, though ittotally confused me at first. but i didn't like what you had shippo do, or really the whole second chapter. it jsut didnt; seem to..... accurate? i dont know, i didn' like the spanking thing, it jsut didnt work for me. but other than that, your story could perhaps have some potential, i cant really say for sure, as i dont know where your story is going yet, but just from what i have read, it seems like it does have some potential.
person PJ
schedule December 24, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Great start. I think she uses that rosary too often and doesn't need it anymore anyways. Maybe at first to keep him from "killing" her but after they started working together then no. Although Inuyasha needs to understand that she needs to go back to her time to try and keep up with her schooling. But yes she also coddles Shippou he needs some boundaries and such because he does act like a brat sometimes. Plus when Inuyasha had the rosary Shippou & even Miroku has sometimes "tricked" Kagome into Sitting him. Yes Kagome did abuse it she would use it when she got just a bit ticked off or if he was a bit rude instead of telling him he was rude or whatever. I am glad she took it off and Shippou so deserved that spanking. What he did was very wrong. Please update soon.